Bransom, TX

a discussion place for our web site


You are not connected. Please login or register

BOTD 7/11/13 "Who's Singing The Blues?" A Late Chat Production

View previous topic View next topic Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

David M. Katz


Marshall
WHO'S SINGING THE BLUES?
A Late Chat Production*
* Leti, Jkher, John Boy and DMK


You are a twenty-two year old Junior at the local university.  You have a thirteen year old brother, Dawson.  Your father passed away shortly after Dawson was born.  You are very close to Dawson and have helped your single mother with Dawson as much as you could.  Often it seems Dawson looks to you more as a father figure than a big brother. Your mother typically handles Dawson's discipline and, when he was younger, her preferred punishment for Dawson had been spanking.  As Dawson has gotten older she no longer feels comfortable with spanking and has used grounding.  

There is an outdoor blues music festival in your community and you and a group of friends purchase tickets to attend.  Dawson over hears you discussing the festival and, being a lover of the genre himself, wants to attend.  Your mother does not feel comfortable with Dawson attending the festival.  For the record she doesn't feel comfortable with you attending but you are an adult.  There will be copious amounts of alcohol at the event and, though not officially condoned, it is rumored that illegal drugs will be available. One of the groups performing also has some sexually explicit music and their act is considered lewd.  Your mother forbids Dawson from attending and you support her decision as well. As an adult you feel the festival is appropriate for you but do admit that it is no place for a minor.

On the day of the festival, Dawson sneaks over the fence and makes it into the event.  It is an extremely hot day and Dawson tries to purchase beer but is unsuccessful.  However he does manage to get  beer from some of the more sympathetic attendees.  A security guard at the event notices Dawson.  Not only is Dawson observed drinking beer he does not have the required armband showing he is a paid attendee.  The security guard stops Dawson and a verbal confrontation ensues.  Dawson is allowed to call you on your cell.  You are surprised he is at the festival.  You are allowed to "take custody" of Dawson as soon as he is escorted out of the event area.  You take Dawson home and stand to miss part of the festival you paid to see.



DAWSON - 13
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]



You tell Dawson that you will be letting your mother know what happened.  Dawson starts pleading with you to not tell your mother.  Not only does he not want to be grounded he also seriously does not want to disappoint her. Dawson begs you to keep the matter "just between us brothers."  Dawson then tells you that you can give him a spanking.  Dawson tells you that you can wear him out but he does not want your mother to know.

You can:
1. Let the matter pass with no punishment and without telling your mother.
2.  Give Dawson the "spanking of his life" and keep the matter "between brothers."
3.  Tell your mother and let Dawson be grounded.
4.  Tell your mother but suggest that a spanking would be more appropriate than grounding  and offer to give the spanking.

What do you do?  Is there another option that you have not thought of?



Last edited by David M. Katz on Wed Jul 10, 2013 6:38 pm; edited 2 times in total (Reason for editing : Corrected a continuity issue.)


_________________
Cleverly disguised as a responsible adult.
http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=David+M.+Katz

1strappedboy


Sherrif
If my only options are those listed, I'll choose #4. That way my personal honor is satisfied in that I haven't lied to my mother who has obviously done a pretty good job at raising me without a father.

I can also be a good 'big brother' to Dawson who needs to observe the rules perhaps a bit better. I agree that being grounded for ages is not a 'preferred' punishment and I am rather certain that Dawson realizes that he does deserve something for this breach of behavior. Since he looks to me as a bit of a father figure anyway, I'm pretty sure that he'd accept a spanking from me as he had said. I just don't want there to be any secrets between our mother and us.

kalico


Sherrif
Very Happy  Im going with #1 and just playing the "BIG BROTHER" role, as I have not really handled any real punishment. Sometimes I think kido's just need a break and who better than your BIG BROTHER to allow that to happen. I will explain to him that if this EVER happens again I wont be so nice and I will be telling mom about it and he can either believe me now and accept that or just try it later and find out.




hugs kal

David M. Katz


Marshall
I was just about ready to jump on Dimitri's wagon when Kal tugged at my heart strings. Dawson's getting a pass - this time.


_________________
Cleverly disguised as a responsible adult.
http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=David+M.+Katz

John Boy


Sherrif
I say option 4 and he can pay me back for my wasted concert ticket.

http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=John+Boy

David M. Katz


Marshall
John Boy wrote:I say option 4 and he can pay me back for my wasted concert ticket.

Meanie Laughing  Razz 


_________________
Cleverly disguised as a responsible adult.
http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=David+M.+Katz

John Boy


Sherrif
David M. Katz wrote:
John Boy wrote:I say option 4 and he can pay me back for my wasted concert ticket.

Meanie Laughing  Razz 
Hey I work hard for my money and if I spend it on something I expect to enjoy it not have to leave early. Razz

http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=John+Boy

Kat


Editor Extraordinaire
This is tough. I really sympathize with Dawson. It's difficult to accept that you're too young for certain things when you're thirteen. As Kal says, I'm a brother, not a parent. I think there should be a certain solidarity among siblings. I have neither forgiven nor forgotten that one of my sibs broke that agreement by reporting something I'd done to our parents. (I had covered for him plenty of times.) Different people play different roles in our lives. I want a younger brother to feel I'm someone he can turn to who is not part of the "adult conspiracy". There is a substantial age difference, but I don't think it's enough for me to assume the parental role. There might come a time when I agree to be the designated hitter and carry out a punishment decreed by our mother, but I won't assign punishments myself; and I will do my best to be Dawson's ally, breaking that sibling bond only if I feel he is in real danger.

Kat

Padraig


Trailboss
I think I will drop him off at home, tell him we will talk tomorrow and head back to the concert.

If this is his first stunt of this kind I don't think mom has to be involved. But he will know I'm not happy. However, how he will make it to his room without getting her attention is his problem.

ivor


Marshall
My inclination is to #4, but then I didn't have a brother so it is hard to tell how my views might be different had that been the case. Kat makes a good case for #1 it has to be said.

http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=Ivor+slipper

MemoryMan


Sherrif
Can I start a "P" club?

(Having looked at the pic a spanking is on the cards for tomorrow tho') Twisted Evil

http://www.malespank.net/listAuthor.php?author=MemoryMan

Jack


Admin
I started to not answer this one, and had to read over the other answers to get any kind of an idea.

I'm going with #1.

For one thing, I agree with Kat that it's hard to accept that there are some things that you're too young for when you're a kid.

My problem is that this isn't one of them.

There's going to be beer, and maybe even illegal drugs there! Great Mom, does that mean I don't have to go to school? I don't know how much beer was actually at school, but I know how many beer drinkers we had. And I know we actually had drug (pot) related arrests occur AT THE SCHOOL when I was there.

And adult lyrics? My gosh, does that mean you're going to start turning off the TV and quit letting me go to PG-13 movies, Mom?

Sorry, if I really wanted to be a good, big brother, I should have persuaded Mom to let me take Dawson, so I could have supervised him. As it is, he managed to get here on his own. I'll make sure he has money to get a Gatorade on the way home, then I'm going back to the show.

http://bransomtx.forumotion.net

squarecutter


Sherrif
I think our Mother needs to know and ultimately this will be her call. I will , though Dawson may get in first, suggest a severe spanking for Dawson, and yes iI Mum wishes, I would be prepared to deliver it. I suggest hairbrush or paddle and a switch if Dawson attempts to re- enter the festival. I think if this happens Dawson may not feel much like going anywhere when I'm done with him. So option 4

Guest


Guest
As I sit at my computer and write, I know that option # 4 is correct. Specifically, what I would do is explain to him that the real issue here is disobeying mom, and that if I were to go behind her back I'd be disrespecting her as well. I would also explain to him that, given that mom only spanked him as a little boy and then stopped, he probably doesn't have any idea what a spanking at 13 from big brother would look like. I'd explain it to him, and if he still prefers it over grounding, I'll suggest it to mom. My guess is that once he understands, he'll opt for the grounding.

There's just one problem with this scenario, and it's in the first words of the story; "You are a twenty-two year old..."

OK, yeah, that changes everything. The me that was once 22 would definitely go for option # 2. Specifically, I would negotiate with him just how severe a spanking he was willing to take - preferably something involving him lying naked across a bed and me with a belt in my hand.

Of course, I never had a little brother, and maybe that responsibility would have made me a wiser 22 year old. I doubt it, though.

Pi Beta


Deputy
If tickets are still available and if, after being caught, Dawson still wants to attend, I will suggest to him that I ring our mother and explain what has happened to try to persuade her to let him stay with me since I don't want to have to miss any more of the event than I have already because of him.

Indeed, it might be that I will not be allowed back in myself without having to pay for another ticket if I leave the event area completely, in which case I would be suggesting to mother that she would need to come to collect Dawson - something she might be very reluctant to do.

Dawson would realise that punishment for disobedience would be due - what punishment would need to be determined when he and I get home if I persuade mother to let him stay. I would volunteer to whack him on her behalf if she was inclined to think that more appropriate than a grounding - indeed, I would try to persuade her to agree to that, thus going part way along Dawson's plea to avoid a grounding.

In return for Dawson's co-operation, I would "forget" to mention his success in obtaining some beer.

Not sure mum will agree but hope so, even though I'm not at all keen on having my kid brother with me the rest of the day but nor do I want to miss any more of the event.

Iconoclast


Trailboss
Jack wrote:I started to not answer this one, and had to read over the other answers to get any kind of an idea.

I'm going with #1.

For one thing, I agree with Kat that it's hard to accept that there are some things that you're too young for when you're a kid.  

My problem is that this isn't one of them.

There's going to be beer, and maybe even illegal drugs there!  Great Mom, does that mean I don't have to go to school?  I don't know how much beer was actually at school, but I know how many beer drinkers we had.  And I know we actually had drug (pot) related arrests occur AT THE SCHOOL when I was there.

And adult lyrics?  My gosh, does that mean you're going to start turning off the TV and quit letting me go to PG-13 movies, Mom?

Sorry, if I really wanted to be a good, big brother, I should have persuaded Mom to let me take Dawson, so I could have supervised him.  As it is, he managed to get here on his own.  I'll make sure he has money to get a Gatorade on the way home, then I'm going back to the show.

I agree!

Iconoclast

Stone Man


Marshall
I will give Dawson a set amount of time to tell our Mother with the promise that I have to tell her if he doesn't. He and our Mom can work out the details of his punishment. I have no problem with whippin' him if that is what they settle on.

Sponsored content


View previous topic View next topic Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum